Reference | US Mode | Transducer, and Technical Specifications | No. Sites Evaluated | Scanning Protocol and Position of the Patient | US Image Reader Blinded |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Gutierrez14 | GS | Convex probe, MyLab 70 XVG (Esaote S.p.A.), 2–7 MHz | 50 and 14 | Standardized technique. Patient positions were supine or near-supine for the anterior chest scanning, while in a sitting position for the posterior chest scanning. | Yes |
Aghdashi19 | GS | Linear probe, Siemens sonoline G-40 (Siemens), 7–10 MHz | 10 | Standardized technique. Patients were examined in supine position for assessment of anterior chest wall and in sitting position for assessment of posterior chest wall. | NR |
Barskova20 | GS | Cardiac sector transducer 2.5 cm in length (Mylab50, Esaote), 2.5–3.5 MHz | 72 | Standardized technique. Patients in the supine position for anterior and lateral scanning, and in the sitting position for dorsal scanning. | No |
Buda21 | GS | Linear probe 8–11MHz, convex probe 3.5–5MHz, Logiq 7 system (GE Healthcare) | NR | Standardized technique. Patients remaining in the sitting and supine position. | NR |
Gargani11 | GS | Convex probe, cardiac sector transducer (2.5 cm long), Mylab25 (Esaote), 2.5–3.5 MHz | NR | Standardized technique. Patients in the supine or near-supine position for the anterior scanning, and in the sitting position for the dorsal scanning. | Yes |
Gigante22 | GS | Convex probe, Toshiba Ultrasound System, 2.5 to 3.5 MHz | NR | Standardized technique. Position of patients NR. | No |
Moazedi-Fuerst23 | GS | Convex probe 3.5 MHz, linear probe NR | NR | Standardized technique. The anterior pleural surface was investigated in a supine position while the lateral and posterior surfaces were scanned in a sitting position. | NR |
Pinal-Fernandez24 | GS | Linear probe. MyLabTwice system, 5 MHz | 72 | Standardized technique. Patients in supine position to record the anterior and anterolateral sonographic points and in sitting position for the posterior and posterolateral ones. | NR |
Sperandeo12 | GS | Convex probe, 3.5–5 MHz | NR | Protocol and patient position NR. | NR |
Tardella13 | GS | Convex probe, MyLab 70 XVG (Esaote Biomedica) equipped 2–7 MHz | 50 | Patients in the supine or near-supine position (with the arms elevated and hands clasped behind the neck) for anterior and lateral scanning, and in the sitting position (with the arms along the trunk) for posterior scanning. | Yes |
Moazedi-Fuerst10 | GS | Convex probe and linear probe, 3.5 MHz | 18 | Standardized technique. The anterior pleural surface was investigated in a supine position while the lateral and posterior surface was scanned in a sitting position. | NR |
Mohammadi25 | GS | Linear probe, Medison Accuvix V20, 7–10 MHz | 10 | Standardized technique. Patients were examined in supine position for assessment of anterior chest wall and in sitting position for the posterior chest wall. | NR |
US: ultrasound; GS: greyscale; NR: not registered.