Table 5.

Simplified overview* of the development methods for the included quality measurement sets.

Measure Set, AuthorInitial QM DevelopmentConsensus ProcedureMeasure Development Team
AF QI set, MacLean, et al11Nonsystematic literature reviewModified RAND/UCLA AMPhysicians
Monitoring of the disease course in RA, van Hulst, et al16Systematic reviewModified RAND/UCLA AMPhysician
QM for the process of care in JIA, Lovell, et al10Discussions/questionnaires with those involvedModified Delphi + NGTPhysicians + AHP + patients
Eumusc RA QI, Petersson, et al18Systematic reviewStudy-specific consensus methodsPhysicians + AHP + patients
KPI to evaluate centralized intake, Barber, et al6Nonsystematic literature reviewModified RAND/UCLA AMPhysicians + AHP + patients
Cardiovascular QI, Barber, et al7Systematic reviewModified RAND/UCLA AMPhysicians + AHP + patients
AAC system-level performance measures, Barber, et al8Non-systematic literature reviewModified RAND/UCLA AMPhysicians + AHP + patients
QI for physiotherapy management, Peter, et al17Guideline or clinical care pathwayModified Delphi with modified RAND/UCLA AMPhysicians + AHP + patients
ACR RA EQM, Yazdany, et al12Guideline or clinical care pathwayModified RAND/UCLA AMPhysicians + AHP + patients
NCQA/PCPI/ACR, Kwoh, et al9Guideline or clinical care pathwayStudy-specific consensus methodsPhysicians + AHP + patients
QOF-RA, NICE-QOF15Guideline or clinical care pathwayStudy-specific consensus methodsPhysicians + AHP + patients
QS for RA, NICE13Guideline or clinical care pathwayStudy-specific consensus methodsPhysicians + AHP + patients
QS for PsA, NICE14Guideline or clinical care pathwayStudy-specific consensus methodsPhysicians + AHP + patients
  • * For extended version, see Supplementary material, available with the online version of this article. AAC: Arthritis Alliance of Canada; ACR: American College of Rheumatology; AF: Arthritis Foundation; AHP: allied health professionals; Eumusc: European Musculoskeletal Conditions Surveillance and Information Network; EQM: electronic quality measures; JIA: juvenile idiopathic arthritis; KPI: key performance indicators; NCQA: (US) National Committee for Quality Assurance; NICE: (UK) National Institute for Health and Care Excellence; NGT: nominal group technique; PCPI: physician consortium performance improvement; PsA: psoriatic arthritis; QI: quality indicator; QM: quality measure; QOF: quality and outcomes framework; QS: quality standard; RA: rheumatoid arthritis; RAND/UCLA AM: RAND/University of California, Los Angeles Appropriateness Method.