Table 1.

Summary of studies used in the review.

StudiesStudy YrsFollowup DurationOutcomes AnalyzedTotal, nWhite, nBlack, nSignificantly Worse in Black PatientsAge AdjustedSex AdjustedLOS AdjustedComorbidity AdjustedAdjusted SESNotes
Maratt, et al182001–20072 yrsWOMAC pain, stiffness, function23222108101PainYesYesYesYesYesRetrospective analysis of consecutive prospective cases
Barrack, et al21NA1–4 yrsUWSC, satisfaction*, function66157385Pain, function**YesYesRetrospective analysis of consecutive prospective cases
Jacobs, et al23NA2–5 yrsSatisfaction98983049SatisfactionYesYesNoRetrospective analysis of consecutive prospective cases
Kamath, et al2020042–5 yrsROM, KSS1858790Pain, function, ROMYesNoRetrospective study
Lavernia, et al191992–20072–16 yrsROM, WOMAC, HSS, KSRS101017674Pain, functionYesNoSingle surgeon, retrospective analysis of consecutive prospective cases
Lopez-Olivo, et al222004–20056 mosWOMAC pain and function, KSRS total, KSRS function24116661FunctionYesYesProspective cohort study
Styron, et al171, 3, 6 mosWOMAC, SF-1216213722Pain, functionYesYesProspective cohort study
  • * Survey designed by the UWSC; targeted satisfaction with overall knee function, ability to perform daily activities, and pain relief using a 5-point Likert scale.

  • ** Questions worse in black and Hispanic patients included: problems getting in and out of the car or chair, difficulty going up and down stairs, experienced pain in the last 30 days, and limp while walking.

  • Patients were asked if they were satisfied with their surgery and given the options “yes,” “no,” or “I’m not sure” — “yes” were categorized as satisfied. LOS: length of hospital stay; SES: socioeconomic status; NA: not applicable; WOMAC: Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index; UWSC: University of Wisconsin Survey Center; ROM: range of motion; KSS: Knee Society Score; HSS: Hospital for Special Surgery; KSRS: Knee Society Rating Score; SF-12: Medical Outcomes Study Short Form-12.