Table 1.

Enthesitis measures used in randomized controlled trials in psoriatic arthritis.

Enthesis MeasureMethod (score range)Trials in PsAValidation in PsA
Modified Mander Enthesitis Index25,25aTenderness at 21 sites, scored at each site on 4-point scale: 0 = no pain; 1 = mild tenderness; 2 = moderate tenderness; 3 = wince or withdrawal. 1st cervical spinous process; 2nd cervical spinous process; 7th cervical spinous process; 1st thoracic spinous process; 12th thoracic spinous process; 1st lumbar spinous process; 5th lumbar spinous process; 1st sacral spinal process; symphysis pubis; greater trochanters, left, right (L,R); pelvic abductor origin (L,R); anterior superior border of the iliac crest (L,R); ischial tuberosity (L,R); Achilles tendon insertion (L,R); plantar fascia insertion (L,R)Clegg 199615No
IMPACT Index9Tenderness (yes/no) at 4 sites (0–4); Achilles tendon insertion (L,R); Plantar fascia insertion (L,R)Antoni 20058,9; Mease 200510; Genovese 200711; Gottlieb 200913; Sterry 201014No
Maastricht AS Enthesitis Score (MASES)26Tenderness (yes/no) at 13 sites (0–13). 1st Costochondral joint (L,R); 7th Costochondral joint (L,R); Posterior superior iliac spine (L,R); Anterior superior iliac spine (L,R); Iliac crest (L,R); 5th Lumbar spinous process; Proximal insertion of Achilles tendon (L,R)Kavanaugh 201418 Ritchlin 201419No
PsA Modified MASES12Tenderness (yes/no) at 15 sites (0–15). 1st Costochondral joint (L,R); 7th Costochondral joint (L,R); Posterior superior iliac spine (L,R); Anterior superior iliac spine (L,R); Iliac crest (L,R); 5th Lumbar spinous process; Proximal insertion of Achilles tendon (L,R); Plantar fascia insertion (L,R)Kavanaugh 20097,12; McInnes 201316No
Leeds Enthesitis Index (LEI)5Tenderness (yes/no) at 6 sites (0–6); lateral epicondyle (L,R); medial femoral condyle (L,R); Achilles tendon insertion (L,R)Mease 201417Yes27, clinical LEI, odds ratio: 2.16 (0.81–5.70) for PsA vs RA