Table 1.

Study quality assessment.

Quality AssessmentTICORA 11Fransen12CAMERA13
Method of randomization adequateYYY
Patient blindedNNN
Care providers blindedNNN
Outcome assessors blindedNYN
Treatment allocation concealedYYY
Groups similar at baseline regarding the most important prognostic factorsYYY
Cointerventions avoided or similarNYN
Timing of outcome assessment in both groups comparableYYY
Compliance acceptable in all groupsYYN
Dropout rate described and acceptableYYN*
Intention to treat analysis usedYYY
  • * High dropout rate. Y: yes; N: no.